On the Origins of Judaism: An Exchange
In our Winter 2024 issue, Malka Simkovich took a deep dive into Yonatan Adler’s thought-provoking new book, The Origins of Judaism: An Archeological-Historical Reappraisal. Her review explored Adler’s argument that Judaism as we know it did not emerge until the Hasmonean era, and before then our ancestors were not, to use a modern phrase, Torah Observant. Simkovich highlight’s what she found to be the book’s successes, and criticizes what she sees to be Adler’s more radical readings about Judaism’s beginnings.
Our goal as a magazine is to create and invite dialogue from those who agree and disagree with one another, to build a respectful and productive space for conflicting ideas. That is why we’re very glad to publish an exchange between Yonatan Adler and Malka Simkovich about the book and the review. Both writers are passionate about their fields, confident in their ideas, and respectful of each other’s scholarship. We enjoyed reading their back-and-forth, and you will too.
- Read Yonatan Adler’s defense of his book here.
- And read Malka Simkovich’s response here.
Suggested Reading

What . . . Him Worry?
How did Abraham Jaffee, raised in the shtetl of Zarasai, became one of MAD magazine's most prolific and recognizable cartoonists?

I Have Come to My Garden
Without the Torah, says Rabbi Akiva, we would still be able to discover all its truths by delving deeply into the words of the Song of Songs.

“I’m Eighty-Five Years Old, Bubba’leh”
"Feel free to also call me ‘Rabbi’ or ‘Professor.’ Neither offends me. No, not ‘Motti.’ Never ‘Motti.’ If you want to call someone Motti, why don’t you go downstairs and talk to the guy at the corner store?" An excerpt from The Ghost Editor.
The Shtetl Trap
How should we think about the Eastern European market town? Did the shtetl ever have a golden age?
Comments
You must log in to comment Log In